Baseball America presents its 2025 College All-America teams. Tennessee leads the way with three first-team All-Americans in 1B Andrew Fischer, 2B Gavin Kilen and LHP Liam Doyle. LSU, Oklahoma and Florida State are also well-represented across the three teams.
The first team roster is as follows, and writeups are included below. The second and third teams are located at the bottom of the post.
First Team
Carson Tinney, C, Notre Dame
Tinney enjoyed one of the biggest breakout seasons of any hitter in the country and posted a .348/.498/.753 slash line with 13 doubles, 17 homers and 53 RBIs. In addition to his plus power, Tinney is an advanced defender behind the plate.
Andrew Fischer, 1B, Tennessee
Fischer thrived in his lone season at Tennessee and hit .341/.497/.760 with 16 doubles, 25 homers, 65 RBIs and an eye-popping 63-to-42 walk-to-strikeout ratio. He stands out for his advanced approach, but Fischer also possesses plus power to the pull side and a feel for the barrel.
Gavin Kilen, 2B, Tennessee
Speaking of players who flourished in Knoxville, Kilen hit a career-best .357/.441/.671 with 32 extra-base hits, a career-high 46 RBIs and 30 walks to 27 strikeouts. He tapped into more power this spring to go along with his advanced feel to hit. Kilen could be a first-round pick this July.
Roch Cholowsky, SS, UCLA
Cholowsky has long been a well-known amateur prospect, and this spring he hit the world on fire to the tune of a .353/.480/.710 slash line with 19 doubles, 23 home runs, 74 RBIs with 45 walks to 30 strikeouts. A plus defender at shortstop, Cholowsky also has an enticing hit-power combination and has a chance to be the first overall pick in 2026.
Daniel Cuvet, 3B, Miami
Cuvet continued to build on the momentum from his standout freshman campaign and hit .372/.450/.708 with 20 doubles, 18 home runs and a whopping 84 RBIs. Cuvet has some of the most impressive raw power in his class and has shown no issue getting to it in games.
Ike Irish, OF, Auburn
Irish is one of the more complete hitters in this year’s draft class. He has hit at every stop and this season was the best of his career, as he hit .364/.469/.710 with 13 doubles, a career-high 19 home runs and 58 RBIs. Where he sticks defensively is a bit of a question mark, but his comfortably plus arm plays both behind the plate and in a corner outfield spot.
Devin Taylor, OF, Indiana
Another complete hitter, Taylor has one of the lengthier track records of performance of any bat in this year’s draft class. He most recently hit a career-best .374/.494/.706 with 33 extra-base hits, a career-high 66 RBIs and 52 walks to just 30 strikeouts. A left fielder defensively, Taylor’s bat could be enough to warrant a first-round selection.
James Quinn-Irons, OF, George Mason
Quinn-Irons enjoyed the best season of any mid-major bat in the country. He posted a gaudy .419/.523/.734 slash line with 42 extra-base hits, 85 RBIs and 36 stolen bases. Quinn-Irons has a big league body—with impressive tools to boot—and moves better than his 6-foot-5, 230-pound listing would suggest.
Alex Lodise, DH, Florida State
Lodise was the centerpiece of Florida State’s super regional run and hit a career-best .394/.462/.705 with 18 doubles, 17 home runs and 68 RBIs—all of which were new career highs. Lodise is also an above-average defender at shortstop with a plus arm, and this year he showed the ability to drive the baseball to all fields.
Liam Doyle, LHP, Tennessee
The cornerstone of Tennessee’s rotation, Doyle went 10-1, 3.20 with a whopping 164 strikeouts to 32 walks across 95.2 innings. Armed with one of the best fastballs in the country and an explosive delivery, Doyle simply overpowered hitters all season. He very well could come off the board within the first five picks of this year’s draft.
Kade Anderson, LHP, LSU
The 2025 NCAA strikeout king, Anderson was the ace of one of the best rotations in college baseball. He compiled a 3.44 ERA to go along with a sparkling 11-1 record and 170 strikeouts against just 30 walks. Anderson is armed with an impressive four-pitch mix and presents an exciting blend of present stuff and upside.
Anthony Eyanson, RHP, LSU
It’s no shock that Anderson and Eyanson were perhaps the best one-two rotation punch in college baseball. A transfer from UC San Diego, Eyanson took off in Baton Rouge. He worked a career-best 2.92 ERA with a career-high 143 strikeouts in 101.2 innings. Eyanson has always been an advanced strike-thrower, but this year his entire arsenal took a step forward.
Kyson Witherspoon, RHP, Oklahoma
In the wake of a quality sophomore season and breakout summer, Witherspoon this spring took his game to a different level. He went 10-4, 2.65 and posted a career-high 124 strikeouts against just 23 walks across 95 innings. Witherspoon has advanced command, but his pure stuff is arguably even more impressive.
Dylan Volantis, LHP, Texas
The lone freshman to be named a first team All-American, Volantis quickly cemented himself as one of the most effective relievers in the sport. Across 23 appearances that spanned 51 innings, Volantis worked a 1.94 ERA with 74 strikeouts against just 12 walks. He attacks hitters with a deadly fastball-breaking ball combination, a one-two punch that generated plenty of empty swings.
Gabe Craig, RHP, Baylor
A “fireman” in every sense of the word, Craig compiled a microscopic 0.56 ERA with 51 strikeouts to only three walks across 32 innings. He collected 10 saves in 24 appearances and his combination of strikes and stuff overwhelmed hitters.
Evan Dempsey, TWP, Florida Gulf Coast
Not only did Dempsey pitch his way to a 1.97 ERA—the second-lowest mark in the country—but he also hit .309/.393/.435 with 23 extra-base hits, 30 RBIs and 14 stolen bases. His pitching numbers are even more impressive considering 10 of his 15 appearances were starts. Across 68.2 innings, Dempsey collected 75 strikeouts and walked 20.
Second Team
C: Boston Smith, Wright State
1B: Jared Jones, LSU
2B: Ryan Daniels, UConn
SS: Aiva Arquette, Oregon State
3B: Ace Reese, Mississippi State
OF: Sawyer Strosnider, TCU
OF: Ryan Wideman, Western Kentucky
OF: Gavin Turley, Oregon State
DH: Wehiwa Aloy, Arkansas
SP: Jacob Morrison, Coastal Carolina
SP: Zane Taylor, UNC Wilmington
SP: Blake Gillespie, Charlotte
SP: Jamie Arnold, Florida State
RP: Tony Pluta, Arizona
RP: Antoine Jean, Houston
TWP: Bryce Calloway, New Orleans
Third Team
C: Easton Carmichael, Oklahoma
1B: Mulivai Levu, UCLA
2B: Nick Monistere, Southern Miss
SS: Marek Houston, Wake Forest
3B: Bobby Boser, Florida
OF: Mason Neville, Oregon
OF: Drew Burress, Georgia Tech
OF: Korbyn Dickerson, Indiana
DH: Justin Lebron, Alabama
SP: Jake Knapp, North Carolina
SP: Jack Ohman, Yale
SP: Joseph Dzierwa, Michigan State
SP: JB Middleton, Southern Miss
RP: Ty Van Dyke, Stetson
RP: Dylan Crooks, Oklahoma
TWP: Noah Sullivan, Mississippi State
This post was originally published on this site be sure to check out more of their content.
