No. 2 pick: Travis Hunter, WR/CB, Colorado
Analysis: Reuter also highlighted Hunter as the top talent of the 2025 draft class, writing that he can play on both sides of the ball due to his intelligence, quickness and ball skills.
No. 33 pick: Josh Conerly Jr., OT, Oregon
Analysis: While Reuter wrote that he thinks the Browns can wait until Day 2 to pick a quarterback, with the second-round pick, Reuter selects Conerly for the Browns. Conerly appeared in 41 career games over three seasons at Oregon and played 929 offensive snaps at left tackle in 2024.
No. 2 pick: Abdul Carter, Edge, Penn State
Analysis: Yates writes that while Hunter is his top prospect, Carter is right behind him. The pairing of Carter and DE Myles Garrett as the edge rushers in Cleveland could create an elite pass-rush duo, as Carter recorded 12 sacks during the 2024 season.
No. 33 pick: Tyler Shough, QB, Louisville
Analysis: Yates writes that Day 2 is the place for the Browns to take their quarterback and can do so with Shough at No. 33. With an arm strength that led to 23 touchdowns during the 2024 season, Shough could compete with Pickett for the starting quarterback job.
