‘He’s going to take that team over’ – NFL-bound Vols discuss what’s next for Nico Iamaleava

INDIANAPOLIS — There was no Tennessee quarterback at the 2025 NFL Scouting Combine, but the Tennessee quarterback still came up several times during the media interviews of three Vols who were. Following in the footsteps of Hendon Hooker and Joe Milton III before him, Nico Iamaleava was Tennessee’s first-year starter in 2024 and helped the Vols to a 10-win regular season, a College Football Playoff berth and another top-10 finish. Next season he won’t have the likes of SEC Offensive Player of the Year Dylan Sampson and experienced wide receivers Bru McCoy and Dont’e Thornton Jr. around him – not to mention four starters on the offensive line – those three NFL-bound Vols still expect big things from Iamaleava in 2025.

Iamaleava has been the face of head coach Josh Heupel’s program since his first start against Iowa in the Citrus Bowl on New Year’s Day in 2024, but the identity of Tennessee’s 2024 team was the heroics of Sampson powering the SEC’s No. 1 rushing offense and an elite defense that only gave up more than 20 points three times in 13 games.

The Vols should remain strong on defense, but Iamaleava almost certainly will have to be more directly involved with the success of the offense. With an overhauled, inexperienced receiving corps, a new-look offensive line and a backfield replacing its star around him, Iamaleava must take his own steps and also elevate the play of those around him. As he transitions into his second season as the Tennessee starting quarterback, that’s what his former teammates expect him to do.

“I think his confidence is just going to continue to grow and grow,” McCoy said. “As he gets older, and especially having Mike (Matthews) there, too, he’ll just continue to develop. He’s getting bigger, stronger, faster. His arm strength’s already there, and the more time you have in the offense Coach Heup runs, the easier it is to do stuff, so I think you’ll see a similar outcome to what Joe and Hendon were able to do. He’s got a lot of good stuff ahead of him.”

The 6-foot-6, 215-pound Iamaleava was the No. 2-ranked player in the 2023 recruiting cycle out of Long Beach, Calif., and he was a larger-than-life figure on multiple fronts given his celebrity among Tennessee fans following his commitment to the Vols in March 2022 and pioneer status as an NIL market-setter for the quarterback position.

Yet coaches and teammates always cited his humility and maturity, which helped him embrace a role as the backup to Milton during the 2023 season. Both he and Tennessee might have benefited from more playing time during his freshman season, but instead he redshirted. His first meaningful action came in the bowl game in Orlando after Milton opted out.

Iamaleava’s first full season had its ups and downs. He started off strong as the Vols stormed to a 4-0 record and a top-five ranking, but October brought struggles in the Arkansas loss, the overtime escape against Florida and a rough first half against Alabama. Iamaleava briefly exited the matchup with the Crimson Tide and also threw an interception as the Vols were shutout in the first half for a third straight game.

But he came up big with a timely scramble out of pressure to set up one touchdown, a remarkable throw on the run to a streaking Thornton for an explosive play to set up the second touchdown and a pinpoint lob to Chris Brazzell II for the game-winning touchdowns.

“He was always prepared for big games,” Thornton said. “No matter what it was, a lot of people tried to tag that he was a freshman, it’s his first starts, his first season starting in the SEC, but I feel like every game he came in with the mindset that he was going to be the greatest he could be, and he showed that in a lot of those big games.”

Iamaleava appeared to turn a corner in that second half against Alabama. He threw for 292 yards in a win against Kentucky and paced the Vols to a halftime lead against Mississippi State before sitting out the second half with an injury. After a tough loss at Georgia, Iamaleava had back-to-back four-touchdown games against UTEP and Vanderbilt and Tennessee landed a coveted CFP spot.

The first-round matchup at Ohio State turned into a harrowing night for the Vols. With Sampson ailing, Thornton and starting wideout Squirrel White exiting and the offensive line overrun, it felt like Iamaleava was taking on the rampant Buckeyes all by himself. He threw for just 104 yards on 14-of-31 passing and was sacked four times, but he also rushed for 47 yards and scored both of his team’s touchdowns.

Iamaleava showed his toughness in the Alabama and Georgia games, but the most overlooked aspect of him as a player was on display in Columbus.

“How physical he is when he runs the ball, and also how tough he is,” McCoy said. “There’s like this knock on him, maybe, that he’s skinny and that he can’t take hits. I don’t know if you saw the Ohio State game, but he got his helmet cracked open. He just got a new helmet and went right back out there, so the guy’s extremely tough, and he’s a great leader, too. He knows at what moments that he needs to step up and speak up and do his thing, and I’m really excited for what he’s got to come.”

As far as leadership goes, there’s no hiding when you’re the starting quarterback, and Iamaleava had to come out of his shell in 2024. He had to shift from relying on one-on-one interactions to amplifying his voice to other position groups, the offense and the entire team. More teammates will be looking to him in 2025, so Iamaleava must continue to develop and evolve more as a leader this offseason.

“He just comes from a humble and strong foundation of family,” Sampson said. “I’ve seen him take steps over the course of the year, just in his leadership and his growth being a young quarterback, but man, he’s poised. He’s confident. He’s humble. He’s cool, calm and collected, man. He’s going to take that team over. He’s really going to do a good job of growing into that leader that everybody wants to see him to be.”

Said Thornton: “He’s just got to keep being himself, and it’s going to be working out for him.”

Iamaleava and McCoy built a strong connection as California high school stars – Iamaleava recalls watching McCoy dominate as a two-way player at powerhouse Mater Dei when he was younger – and the two players got together for some offseason training on the West Coast back in January with Matthews joining them.

McCoy and the rest of Iamaleava’s former teammates will be keeping an eye on him and the Vols from a distance as they head down their own paths as NFL rookies.

“Nico’s a dog, man,” McCoy said. “As he developed and he came into himself, especially as he got to Tennessee and got under Coach Heupel and in his system – man, I think he’s got a really bright future ahead of him and is going to do a lot of really good things.”