
Until Saturday Newsletter 🏈 | This is The Athletic’s college football newsletter. Sign up here to receive Until Saturday directly in your inbox.
Today in college football news, it’s a great time to join the ever more bustling sports communities on Bluesky. Here’s a bunch of The Athletic people who cover every sport, and here’s the Sickos Committee’s CFB and CFB-adjacent list. With two clicks, you can follow everybody.
Difficulty Spike: The going gets even tougher
Each year, looking ahead at strength of schedule, one thing jumps out at me: Your favorite team is the bravest and hardest-working in all the land, while all your rivals are cowards with sinister haircuts.
This year, I noticed an additional thing: So many of the teams with the roughest schedules are also teams with hot-seat coaches, or at least coaches on the You Can Easily Imagine This Seat Becoming Hot If Several Things Go Wrong seat. Why would anyone sit there? Either way, what a combo!
We could look at this in any of college football’s numerous SOS metrics, but let’s grab a select few of the teams from the top of Bill Connelly’s. How many hot seats do you see?
- No. 1 Oklahoma
- No. 2 Florida
- No. 3 Arkansas
- No. 4 Wisconsin
- No. 6 Mississippi State
- No. 8 Kentucky
- No. 9 LSU
- No. 11 Alabama
- No. 15 Auburn
- No. 20 USC
- No. 30 Florida State
- No. 42 Oklahoma State (the Cowboys aren’t in Bill’s top-40 post, so I asked him about them, because I wanted you to know)
For a lot of reasons that could inspire sprawling arguments, it’s normal for SEC teams to rank highly in both computer ratings and hot-seat lists. But this time, the country’s hardest schedules line up to an eerie degree with Seth Emerson’s SEC hot-seat rankings:
- The teams with the three hardest slates happen to be coached by Seth’s three most-endangered coaches: Arkansas’ Sam Pittman, Florida’s Billy Napier and Oklahoma’s Brent Venables.
- Elsewhere in the nation’s 15 hardest schedules are five more coaches ranked in the scarier half of Seth’s list: Kentucky’s Mark Stoops, LSU’s Brian Kelly, Auburn’s Hugh Freeze, Mississippi State’s Jeff Lebby and Alabama’s Kalen DeBoer. (For the time being, DeBoer will be impossible to rank. More on that below.)
Let’s look at Oklahoma in particular. In three years, Venables (22-17) has overseen the only two losing seasons OU has had since 1998, and now his schedule looks one of those “Elden Ring” challenges where some YouTuber tries to beat the game while using a potato as a controller. (I think I made that up.)
Advertisement
From Stewart Mandel’s way-too-early Top 25, Oklahoma has to play No. 2 Texas, No. 4 LSU, No. 13 Tennessee, No. 14 Alabama, No. 16 South Carolina, No. 18 Michigan, No. 28 Auburn and No. 29 Missouri. I’d also include Ole Miss, ranked No. 9 by SP+. Settle down, ye tarnished!
And even the Sooners’ gimme games involve punishment. For some reason, they’re questing 1,400 miles to visit Temple. That’s half a Big Ten!
- Stay positive: Offense was their problem last year, and Venables brought in the Washington State duo of OC Ben Arbuckle (who also coached Cam Ward) and QB John Mateer (who ranked No. 2 in our portal ranking).
Elsewhere, the hardest non-SEC schedule belongs to Wisconsin — and wouldn’t you know it, things there have been looking perilous anyway.
Check out 2025’s road schedule for Luke Fickell (13-13), who’s fresh off UW’s worst two-year stretch since 1994-95: Alabama, Michigan, Oregon, Indiana and Minnesota. Their combined 2024 record against teams outside that group: 43-10. Oh, and Ohio State’s stopping by Madison.
- Stay positive: Fickell has recruited pretty well, bringing in two of UW’s four highest-rated classes of this millennium. Jesse Temple expects some impact.
You get the idea.
Since we’re looking way ahead anyway, this December could have a highly active coaching carousel. If a bunch of things go sideways at once, look at all the games on Nov. 29 alone that could involve coaching stakes: Alabama-Auburn, Florida State-Florida, LSU-Oklahoma …
(Obviously, that sentence will look funny in hindsight, because odds are decent that multiple of those teams will make the CFP. Stay positive!)
Below, let’s talk more coaching, and in general, to keep up with college and/or football advanced stats from The Athletic, click this link to follow Austin Mock in the app.
Quick Snaps
🥣 Yes, it feels odd to be talking about next season’s coaching carousel even though the preceding one has only just now wrapped up (probably). Over the weekend, Bowling Green hired Tennessee State’s Eddie George back to the Buckeye State.
🐘 That’s an Amherst Mammoths emoji, because this link is about what new Ohio State DC Matt Patricia, best known as an NFL guy, learned in Division III.
Advertisement
💰 Questions about the ACC vs. Clemson/FSU settlement thing, answered. I think Cal deserves more ACC money for being one of 2024’s most entertaining teams.
💰 Tax breaks on NIL money? Sure, why not.
😬 Seth shares an interesting theory on the current trend of spring-game cancellations: “It’s to prevent their players from truly knowing where they stand.” If I don’t know whether I have a good spot on the depth chart, how can I decide to transfer?
🏀 This is March:
Ranking Coaches: Top 25 has become extra tricky
Each year, Stewart Mandel and Bruce Feldman rank college football’s 25 best coaches. Those lists are out today.
Highest-rated guy on Bruce’s list who isn’t on Stew’s: No. 13 Lincoln Riley. Vice versa on Stew’s list: No. 17 Jamey Chadwell.
If you combined both their lists into one, you’d get this composite top five:
- Kirby Smart
- Ryan Day
- Steve Sarkisian
- Kalen DeBoer
- Dabo Swinney
My favorite thing about ranking college football coaches right now is how difficult it gets after, like, No. 1. A few examples:
- Day is the reigning champ, has a 70-10 record at Ohio State and just beat roughly a thousand ranked teams in a single CFP … yet the whole non-Ann Arbor world wanted to fire him at the end of this past regular season, and going 70-10 is more or less just the job of being Ohio State’s coach.
- Besides the top two coaches, Swinney is the only other with an FBS title, and winning two of them at Clemson counts for much more than Smart winning two at Georgia, relative to resources, expectations, etc. Even Swinney’s slump seasons result in ACC titles. Then again, his team hasn’t been elite since 2020 or so.
- And what matters more, when it comes to DeBoer: his outsized success in Division II and in one year at Washington, or his 2024, when he led Alabama’s worst season since 2007?
Nick Saban’s retirement took away one simple answer from this annual ranking exercise, and nobody else is helping to make it much easier either. Honestly, I think I’d move Dabo up a spot or two. He long tried to win in the portal era while ignoring the portal (which also sounds like a YouTuber gaming challenge), but still.
See both those Top 25 coach lists (and more stuff), over on the site.
Question For You
In case you’ve missed it, Alabama and Auburn, long two of the most football-devoted schools (to say the least), suddenly have one of men’s basketball’s most important rivalries, with both of them ranking in the AP top six after splitting their season series. They could even meet for the rubber match in Sunday’s SEC tournament title game.
For Thursday’s newsletter: What would be the equivalent College Football Playoff matchup between two traditional basketball schools? Send me your comp at untilsaturday@theathletic.com.
Advertisement
I know the answer that feels like the obvious pick, but I’m curious what else you might come up with.
Speaking yet again of hoops, last week’s most-clicked: 40 years’ worth of 64-team men’s March Madness champs, ranked.
📫 Love Until Saturday? Check out The Athletic’s other newsletters.
(Top photo: Ed Zurga/Getty Images)







