Where do Penn State football stars land in latest 2025 NFL mock draft from ESPN’s Mel Kiper?

Team across the league took a key step toward building out their 2025 NFL Draft target boards this month via free agency developments. From marquee signings to stinging losses, all 32 rosters have been impacted, further crystallizing positional needs across the field, and placing a greater spotlight on premier prospects making the jump from college.

In the aftermath of that free agent frenzy, longtime ESPN NFL draft expert Mel Kiper released his latest first-round mock draft on Tuesday. This 32-pick projection features a pair of former Penn State players near the top.

Edge rusher Abdul Carter and tight end Tyler Warren are each included inside the top-10 overall selections, reinforcing expectations that Penn State can produce its first such draft tandem since 2000 (defensive lineman Courtney Brown at No. 1; linebacker LaVar Arrington at No. 2).

“Team needs were shook up quite a bit over the past week,” Kiper noted in reference to free agency. “… Here’s my current thinking on how Round 1 could look based on what I’m hearing from execs, scouts and coaches in the league.”

In this mock draft, which marks Kiper’s third since the college football season ended, Miami quarterback Cam Ward leads the way. He heads to the Tennessee Titans with the No. 1 pick, presumably bringing an end to former Penn State QB Will Levis‘ brief run as that franchise’s potential long-term solution.

Kiper also mentioned Carter and Heisman Trophy winner Travis Hunter (Colorado cornerback/receiver) as others under consideration at the top overall spot. Carter comes off the board next, landing with the Cleveland Browns at Pick 2. Kiper gave him a slight nod over Hunter, calling it “really close”.

“I ultimately settled on Carter because he gives Jim Schwartz the second top-tier edge rusher that he has coveted since becoming Cleveland’s defensive coordinator in 2023,” Kiper wrote. “The Browns would suddenly have two great wide-9 pass rushers in Carter and Myles Garrett, who was extended earlier this month after initially requesting a trade.”

The 6-foot-3, 252-pound Carter is considered a slam dunk to become Penn State’s first top-10 draft selection since running back Saquon Barkley (2018). As a junior, he totaled 68 tackles (nation-best 23.5 for loss) with 12 sacks, nine QB hurries, four pass breakups and two forced fumbles. 

A unanimous All-American, Carter continued to prove his value on the season’s biggest stage. Despite suffering an apparent left shoulder injury in the Fiesta Bowl quarterfinal, Carter collected five tackles (two for loss) with one sack, one QB hurry and one pass breakup during an Orange Bowl semifinal loss to Notre Dame.

Injury issues have complicated Carter’s path to the draft a bit. That aforementioned postseason setback, plus a “stress reaction” in his right foot, kept him out of on-field action at the NFL Scouting Combine. However, he is expected to participate at PSU’s upcoming Pro Day.

“He will put on a show at his Pro Day,” Carter’s agent, Drew Rosenhaus, told ESPN.

In Kiper’s mock draft, Warren finds a professional home five picks later. He sends the Nittany Lions’ record-setting tight end to the New York Jets at No. 7.

“I like the idea of giving new quarterback signing Justin Fields help,” Kiper wrote. “Consider how the Jets could use Warren. At Penn State, Warren lined up in just about every imaginable formation, and he produced from all of them. He’s special with the ball in his hands.”

This result would mark the second straight year with a first-round selection from Penn State for that franchise, which snagged offensive tackle Olu Fashanu at No. 11 overall in 2024. Former Florida star Kyle Pitts (No. 4 to the Atlanta Falcons in 2021) is the highest-drafted tight end in NFL history.

As a fifth-year senior, the 6-foot-6, 260-pound Warren set a Penn State record with 104 receptions for 1,244 yards and eight touchdowns. Aside from producing one of the finest pass-catching seasons ever for a tight end, he added 218 yards and four scores as a runner. He finished seventh in Heisman Trophy voting.

After producing only one first-round pick from 2011 through 2020, Penn State could expand that total to seven since 2021. Jahan Dotson, Odafe Oweh, Micah Parsons, Chop Robinson and the aforementioned Fashanu have each landed in Round 1 during this span.

Warren, Carter and other Penn State draft prospects will have an opportunity to impress scouts next Friday, March 28, during annual Pro Day workouts. The 2025 NFL Draft occurs April 24-26 in Green Bay, Wis.