
“That was me tonight.”
Four-seam fastballs and cutters, in and out, up and down – Nestor Cortes put on a clinic on Thursday night against the Cincinnati Reds, tossing six shutout innings to set the stage for a 1-0 Milwaukee Brewers victory at American Family Field.
It was vintage “Nasty Nestor,” and no doubt allayed any lingering concerns anyone might have had about the left-hander’s historically bad debut against his former team, the New York Yankees, five days earlier at Yankee Stadium.
“It was pretty bad,” Cortes said, referring to allowing home runs on his first three pitches, four in the first inning and five in all in a two-inning start that the Brewers went on to lose, 20-9.
“It was embarrassing to me, what happened last time, and I think as a starter you’ve got 30, 32 of these and there’s going to be a lot of bad ones throughout the way, but you’ve just got to learn how to brush them off and go to the next one,” Cortes continued. “That’s what I did.”
Getting through the opening frame unscathed was a good first step and after issuing a leadoff walk Cortes recovered by sandwiching strikeouts around a flyout to right.
BOX SCORE: Brewers 1, Reds 0
From there, he was off and running.
A 1-2-3 second was followed by a third in which he worked around a one-out double and two-out walk, with Cortes helping himself by making a terrific play on a TJ Friedl bunt and then getting the dangerous Elly De La Cruz looking for the third out with runners on the corners.
That punchout began a string of 10 straight batters retired, Cortes working his way through Cincinnati’s lineup three full times and the start of a fourth before manager Pat Murphy pulled the plug at 86 pitches.
Two catchers factored into the performance: The Brewers’ William Contreras and the Reds’ Jose Trevino, a former teammate of Cortes’s with the Yankees.
“I feel like me and Contreras were on the same page all night long,” said Cortes. “All credit’s to him.”
As for Trevino, Cortes mentioned in the wake of his nightmarish start in New York that his ex-mates’ familiarity with how he pitched and his inability to adjust on the fly was as much to blame as anything for what happened.
This time, changes were made. And thanks to a two-out, run-scoring single by Sal Frelick in the fourth, Cortes was able to pitch with a slim lead that ultimately held up the rest of the way.
“I told myself they know who I am, they know what I do and forget about it. That’s not who I am,” he said. “Obviously, today Trevino is over there. He knows me and he’s caught me a lot and he’s probably giving them scouting reports, so I knew I had to switch it up a little bit.
“I think the mix we had today was spot-on.”
In the end, Cortes (1-1) scattered a hit and two walks while striking out six. The fastballs and cutters accounted for 78% of his four-pitch mix, with changeups and sweepers added in to give hitters a different look from time to time.
“That’s typically who I am,” he said. “I’m going to throw a lot of cutters, a lot of fastballs and hopefully do a lot of stuff in between to get you off those two pitches.”
It was a recipe that worked well, and was much more reminiscent of the one that paved the way for a 3.62 ERA and WHIP of 1.13 in 126 career appearances and 85 starts under the glare of the spotlight in the Big Apple.
The start was the first since Oct. 1, 2022 for Cortes in which he went six or more innings with one or fewer hits allowed. And, he dropped his ERA from 36.00 down to 9.00.
“He was great. That’s all I can say,” Murphy said. “He pitched. That’s why that guy’s been around the way he has. That’s why he’s been a coveted player. I mean, that’s a pitcher. That’s a good, old-fashioned pitcher. He’s all of 5-7, you know?
“He just he’s competitor and winner. What he did, really cool.”
Elvis Peguero, Bryan Hudson and Joel Payamps followed Cortes and maintained the shutout, which was the second thrown by the Brewers in their last three games. And over the last three games, Milwaukee’s starters have allowed one or fewer earned runs, the team’s first such streak since Sept. 9-12, 2023.
On the flip side, it was the Reds’ third consecutive 1-0 blanking, making them just the fifth team in major-league history to accomplish the ignominious feat and first since the Philadelphia Phillies from May 11-13, 1960.
“I think it was a thing where he came off a really poor outing,” said Cincinnati manager Terry Francona of Cortes. “And you could tell as he got into the game, his tempo started to pick up, his pitches were a little more crisp. He was gaining confidence.
“That’s what good pitchers do.”
Now, Cortes and the Brewers will wait to see if he makes his next scheduled start, which would come in Milwaukee’s series opener at Colorado next Tuesday. His wife, Alondra, has a due date of April 12 for the couple’s first child.
“I’m really excited about that,” he said. “I can’t wait for her to deliver and hopefully it’s soon. Hopefully the reason I don’t make my next start is the baby’s here.”


