A closer look at Miami’s returning production numbers in 2025

In this modern age of college football that features the NCAA Transfer Portal, talent retention can be a tough task.

The portal makes it difficult to build and maintain depth for the programs that recruit at a top level year after year because many backups at those programs can start elsewhere.

The portal also provides an opportunity for programs to push players out if there is a sense that it is a position that can be upgraded during the offseason.

Every offseason, Bill Connelly of ESPN provides an interesting look at the teams that return the most production and/or import the most production from another team via the portal.

LINK: Check out the entire returning production ranking here.

According to Connelly’s numbers, the 2025 Miami Hurricanes rank 75th in the country while returning 55 percent of its production from the 2024 season. UM must replace a lot of production from the offensive side of the ball in particular, ranking 82nd nationally in the production returning there. The defense ranks 52nd nationally in returning production.

The ESPN expert views Miami as a team that is likely to regress year over year. The biggest weakness, from a returning production standpoint, for the Hurricanes is at wide receiver. The addition of CJ Daniels from LSU helps boost those numbers, but UM lost its top six pass catchers from the 2024 season. Adding proven talent in the spring portal window would help this bunch.

On defense, the Hurricanes must replace productive defensive linemen like Tyler Baron and Simeon Barrow along with top tackler Kiko Mauigoa at linebacker. The Hurricanes will look for young, inexperienced defensive linemen to step up into bigger roles and linebacker will be a position UM looks to address in the spring portal window.

Connelly has his own formula to weight the importance of production at each position group. On offense he gives 40 percent of the overall number to the returning offensive line snaps, 35 percent to the receiving production, 22 percent to the quarterback passing yards, and three percent to running back production.

On the defensive side, Connelly gives 66 percent of his weight to returning production to returning snaps, 19 percent to returning tackles, and 15 percent to returning tackles for loss.

Connelly notes that the national returning production average is the lowest it has been over the past five seasons, peaking in 2021 at 76.7 percent returning production down to 53.7 percent returning production in 2025.

The average returning production in the ACC is 59.1 percent.

Where do the teams on Bill Connelly’s returning production chart stack up? Let’s have a look…

8/31 vs. Notre Dame: 57 percent, No. 62 overall (No. 88 offense, No. 23 defense)

9/6 vs. Bethune-Cookman: FCS opponent

9/13 vs. South Florida: 67 percent, No. 14 overall (No. 38 offense, No. 17 defense)

9/20 vs. Florida: 66 percent, No. 18 overall (No. 36 offense, No. 25 defense)

BYE

10/4 @ Florida State: 61 percent, No. 47 overall  (No. 52 offense, No. 49 defense)

BYE

10/17 vs. Louisville: 58 percent, No. 60 overall (No. 64 offense, No. 54 defense)

10/25 vs. Stanford: 67 percent, No. 13 overall (No. 63 offense, No. 6 defense)

11/1 @ SMU: 53 percent, No. 78 overall (No. 73 offense, No. 83 defense)

11/8 vs. Syracuse: 50 percent, No. 90 overall (No. 115 offense, No. 34 defense)

11/15 vs. NC State: 62 percent, No. 36 overall (No. 18 offense, No. 72 defense)

11/22 @ Virginia Tech: 54 percent, No. 77 overall, (No. 80 offense, No. 59 defense)

11/29 @ Pittsburgh: 64 percent, No. 27 overall (No. 31 offense, No. 43 defense)

The Hurricanes will face five teams who rank inside the top 40 of Connelly’s returning production metric: USF, Florida, Stanford, NC State, and Pittsburgh.

Florida is an interesting case study in the value of returning production. After a slow start to the 2024 season, the Gators hit their stride in the second half of the season and UF is set to return plenty of young players who stepped up into bigger roles as the season progressed. The Gators return quarterback DJ Lagway, running back Jadan Baugh, and four offensive linemen. On defense, UF returns 12 of 20 players who had at least 200 snaps in 2024.

Returning production doesn’t always equal talent and it doesn’t always equal results, but it is an interesting factor that the Hurricanes will have to navigate in 2025.

1. Clemson: 81 percent, No. 1 nationally

2. Stanford: 67 percent, No. 13 nationally

3. Georgia Tech: 64 percent, No. 26 nationally

4. Pittsburgh: 64 percent, No. 27 nationally

5. Boston College: 63 percent, No. 32 nationally

6. NC State: 62 percent, No. 36 nationally

7. Virginia: 61 percent, No. 46 nationally

8. Florida State: 61 percent, No. 47 nationally

9. Duke: 58 percent, No. 59 nationally

10. Louisville: 58 percent, No. 60 nationally

11. Miami: 55 percent, No. 75 nationally

12. Virginia Tech: 54 percent, No. 77 nationally

13. SMU: 53 percent, No. 78 nationally

14. North Carolina: 53 percent, No. 81 nationally

15. California: 52 percent, No. 83 nationally

16. Wake Forest: 50 percent, No. 88 nationally

17. Syracuse: 50 percent, No. 90 nationally

Clemson is the reigning ACC champion and the Tigers return the most production by far in the ACC—and the most in the country. Clemson, who returns quarterback Cade Klubnik and has the most returning production on offense (86 percent) along with the majority of a talented defense that returns 75 percent of the production from 2024, is currently the betting favorite to win the ACC.

Georgia Tech will be an interesting team to watch as the Yellow Jackets return a solid amount of production as a program that continues to improve under Brent Key’s leadership. SMU must replace a lot of important production from 2024, especially on the defensive side. Syracuse needs to replace a lot of production off a 2024 team that got better as the season progressed. The Orange rank 115th in the country in returning production on offense.

Does returning production always equal success? No. Teams that consistently recruit at a high level are built to navigate roster attrition. Texas (No. 103), Georgia (No. 105), Oregon (No. 109), Ole Miss (No. 113), are strong talent acquisition programs who are expected to be in the mix for College Football Playoff spots in 2025.

Do you have concerns about Miami’s returning production in 2025? Comment below.