In times distant, ancient and forgotten, obscured by primordial mists – like five years ago – there existed a fabled tribe of traveling salesmen: the recruiting rainmakers.
These rangers were regarded as the lifeblood of many college football programs throughout the country.
These were innocent times. Simple times. Simpleton times.
A time when college administrators and coaches made all of the money, in keeping with tradition and the ways of the old gods.
These charismatic and persuasive rainmakers were dutifully ranked each year on various recruiting sites as the nation’s elite recruiters and many of them developed outsized reputations as achievers who could deliver a deluge of talent with their incantations and rhetorically seductive text messaging.
They could talk an Eskimo off of a meat wagon and sell ice to buzzards. You may think that I mixed up those idioms, but those scenarios are also extremely difficult. Particularly if it’s seal meat.
One small problem, though. Those rankings did tend to leave out one small aspect of their hypnotic powers of persuasion – their proficiency for delivering bags.
Enter Bagman.
Contrary to libelous insinuations, these were not bags full of dead presidents. That’s unfair, judgmental, and categorically false.
Ben Franklin was never a president.
Ol’ Ben’s Name Image Likeness had a good hit rate, just as he did on the wives of 18th century French noblemen.
The truth is that the services who ranked these great persuaders neglected to mention that a few of them built their reputations on paying off recruits and handlers; their trade not entirely premised on good old fashioned sweat, hustle, and cajolery.
The services pretended not to notice and the bagmen kept feeding the services information. One hand washes the other. Also, no one likes a tattletale.
NIL changed all of that. Seemingly overnight. It put payoffs above board.
An extinction event for the one trick pony bagman.
Several of the old rainmakers just dried up. Their entreaties sans street wampum no longer yielded precipitation. It turns out that they didn’t have much going for them besides their ability to transact and do the dirty work. You don’t hear some of those old familiar hot assistant names much anymore, do you?
Some continued to excel. They were good at other parts of their craft, adapted, and the payoffs had just been the ante to play the game.
Others who played it honestly the whole time – more or less, we’re talking lighter shades of gray – also benefitted.
So what does it all mean now that the bagman is dying off?
Does this sea change mean that we’re now into a post-recruiting model altogether? Because that’s what I keep reading and hearing. Is it now just about the highest NIL bidder, good enough facilities, and a provable NFL track record?
A purely mechanistic exchange of services?
In some instances. But that’s being oversold.
Yes, the one trick pony bagman has seen his demise, but real coaches and recruiters with the ability to connect with people, sell a vision, convince parents that junior is in good hands, persuasively demonstrate an athlete’s fit to a system or culture, gain trust, convey how much the program wants the player, or is, god forbid, an actual mentor who cares more about the young man than the recruiting ranking is still invaluable.
Staff composition should now shade more towards development, scouting prowess, and Xs and Os acumen. The old SEC model of each staff having a couple of pure bagmen, often with dubious football knowledge, is largely over. Staffs will no longer rely as much on hardcore recruiters making up a lion’s share of spots, but the idea that athletes no longer have to be properly courted or build bonds with staff in the NIL Era is a sell that I’m not buying.
I don’t think it’s true.
Most young athletes still yearn for a connection with their coaches and a sense of fitting into a greater culture, even if their decision is partly informed by pure commerce.
NIL threw sharp rocks in the bagman’s trick-or-treat sack, but college football has not entirely entered a post-recruiting era.
Yet.
The post College Football Recruiting: Death Of A Salesman appeared first on On3 .






