
Starting LT: Carter Smith | Backups: Austin Barrett, Evan Lawrence, Austin Leibfried
Starting LG: Bray Lynch | Backups: Drew Evans, Vince Fiacable, Adedamola Ajani
Starting C: Pat Coogan | Backups: Bray Lynch, Drew Evans
Starting RG: Kahlil Benson | Backups: Drew Evans, Vince Fiacable, Adedamola Ajani
Starting RT: Zen Michalski | Backups: Austin Barrett, Evan Lawrence, Austin Leibfried
Indiana will need to replace at least two graduating offensive line starters (Mike Katic, Trey Wedig) and possibly a third due to injury (Drew Evans). The transfer additions of Pat Coogan, Zen Michalski and Kahlil Benson appear to be the logical plug-and-play replacements, but that is not a certainty entering spring camp.
Michalski is no sure-thing after starting just one game in four seasons with the Buckeyes. While his size (6-foot-6, 319 pounds) and former recruiting pedigree (Top247 recruit) portends to an immediate starting role, likely at right tackle, his overall body of work is lacking. There simply isn’t a ton of experience to feel totally confident in with Michalski, which could open the door for a legitimate position battle this fall.
Benson is back in Bloomington after a one-year stint at Colorado didn’t go as planned. Benson began the season as the Buffs’ starting right guard, also moving around to left guard and right tackle, but injuries and inconsistent performance led to an average individual season. But now that Benson is reunited with offensive line coach Bob Bostad, it could be a perfect pairing to finish Benson’s college career on a high note, potentially at starting right guard.
Coogan, a Notre Dame transfer, is as plug-and-play as they come after appearing in 30 career games and making 26 starts in four seasons with the Fighting Irish. Coogan was the leader of Notre Dame’s offensive line and prolific rushing attack this past season on their way to National Champion runner-up. The 6-foot-5, 310-pounder gives Indiana immediate veteran experience in the middle of the offensive line.
On the left side of the line, Carter Smith has returned to hold down starting left tackle duties for a third-straight season, while Bray Lynch could potentially move from right guard, where he started all of 2024, to left guard as IU reshuffles its lineup up front. Smith has a chance to emerge as a legitimate NFL prospect with another strong campaign, and Lynch proved last season that he’s more than capable of starting and holding his own in the Big Ten.
Then there’s also the lingering injury uncertainty with starting left guard Drew Evans, who suffered a torn achilles in November, an injury which typically requires six to nine months to fully recover from. If Evans is forced to miss the start of the season, Indiana will have to turn to unproven underclassmen for depth at each position, unless it adds a veteran transfer during the spring portal window.







