A flurry of reports from last week resulted in two clear tidbits: (1) a presidential college sports commission is coming; and (2) former Alabama (and Michigan State and LSU and Miami Dolphins) coach Nick Saban will likely serve as a co-chair.
Saban addressed the subject for the first time on Wednesday, in an appearance with ESPN’s Paul Finebaum.
“Well, first of all, I don’t know a lot about the commission,” Saban said. “Secondly, I’m not sure we really need a commission. I think that, you know, a lot of people know exactly what the issues are in college football and exactly what we need to do to fix them. I think the key to the drill is getting people together so that we can move it forward.”
Despite his misgivings about the necessity of a commission, Saban never said he’d decline to serve.
Whatever his role, his agenda is clear: less money paid to the players, more money retained by the schools.
“I’m not opposed to players making money,” Saban said. “I don’t want anybody to think that. I just think the system that we’re, you know, the way it’s going right now, it’s not sustainable and probably not in the best interest of the student-athletes across the board, or the game itself. I think we need to protect the brand and the competitive advantages and disadvantage that are being created right now, and I think we can we can fix all that, but I think we know how to do it, and I think not just me, but a lot of people. We just got to get everybody together to do it.”
As usual, the presumption from Saban and those of his perspective is that college football is broken. From the perspective of the players, who enjoy unprecedented compensation and unlimited restrictions on their mobility, no one is claiming that a fix is needed.
Saban’s predictable position meshes with the perception/reality that the colleges are looking to have it both ways, by: (1) creating a set of rules that restricts player pay and transfer rights; and (2) avoiding making players the employees that they obviously are.
“I don’t think it’s in the interest of the players to necessarily be employees, and I think authentic name, image, and likeness is good for players, but I don’t think pay for play is necessarily what we want,” Saban said.
First, who is Saban to speak on whether anything is in the interests of the players? The players can, and should, speak for themselves.
Second, when Saban says he doesn’t believe “pay for play is necessarily what we want,” who’s the “we”? (It sure as hell ain’t those who would be getting paid to play.)
“I mean, what is college?” Saban said. “You know, we all went to college to create value for our future, and I think we want to keep some semblance of that in terms of guys becoming and developing as people and students and development occur[ing] off the field, as well as developing the ability to play at the next level. So you got to have a system that enhances all three of those.”
That’s fine, if a high percentage of college players make it to the next level. They don’t.
Put simply, college football players are majoring in football. But the placement rate at most schools is ridiculously low. Even at the major pro football factories, most of the players don’t make money in the NFL.
So why not let them get paid while they can, especially when they’re creating millions in value? Why restrict their ability to maximize their income at a time when their earning capacity is high? And why keep them from moving from one program where they won’t be playing to a program where they would be? More than anything else, playing opposed to not playing enhances a player’s ability to play at the next level.
The entire situation sucks for the players. And the fix that will be engineered by the federal government will likely harm their broader interests, not help them.
It won’t matter, if the commission doesn’t fairly represent their interests — and if those who clearly want to help the schools (like Saban) will be able to claim without opposition or scrutiny what they think the players’ best interests are or should be.
This post was originally published on this site be sure to check out more of their content.
