COLUMBUS, Ohio — In the latest episode of Buckeye Talk, hosts Stephen Means and Stefan Krajisnik tackled a tantalizing hypothetical: If Ohio State could add any player in college football to its roster, who would make the cut?
The premise was simple but captivating. As Means framed it: “Let’s assume every possible player returning in college football is available for Ohio State to add to its roster this offseason for a second. Based on what this team potentially needs or just because you want them? Because, listen, you’re fans, you’re allowed to just go, I want this guy simply because I want him. Who would you add to this roster?”
What followed was a fascinating exploration of Ohio State’s perceived roster strengths and weaknesses heading into the 2025 season.
The defensive choice came easily for both hosts, with Means decisively stating: “I went with Peter Woods from Clemson.” This wasn’t just a fantasy pick – it addressed what both hosts identified as Ohio State’s most glaring roster concern.
“I think defense was probably easier because I do think there is one kind of glaring hole of where they could use some help,” Means explained, highlighting the defensive tackle position as the clear area of need.
Krajisnik reinforced this assessment bluntly: “Ohio State doesn’t know how it’s going to stop the run. And Peter woods is going to help you stop the run.”
The Clemson defensive tackle’s credentials speak volumes. As Krajisnik detailed: “Peter Woods, Clemson defensive tackle. The last two years he’s had 54 tackles, 12 tackles for loss, three sacks, and he’s forced two fumbles. He’s also had, he had 20 pressures last year and he had 20 pressures the year before that.”
The offensive selections proved more challenging, reflecting the hosts’ confidence in Ohio State’s skill positions. Krajisnik explained, “On offense, Stephon Spencer Fano from Utah is at the end. probably Proctor are at the top of my list.”
Means ultimately selected Alabama offensive tackle Kadyn Proctor, noting: “I went with Proctor, but Fano is probably option B if I were to list them like that.” The selection of an offensive lineman reveals an interesting dynamic – while not viewed as a desperate need, the hosts prioritized solidifying the offensive line over adding more weapons to an already loaded skill position group.
Perhaps most intriguing was the “wildcard” category, where Means revealed: “So my wild card is DJ Lagway.” The Florida quarterback represents the ultimate luxury pick – not necessarily addressing a need, but potentially raising Ohio State’s ceiling even higher.
What makes this conversation particularly compelling is how it exposes both hosts’ assessment of Ohio State’s current roster construction. While texters chimed in with their own dream additions, one message captured the underlying reality: “Overall, it feels like OSU has one of the best rosters in the country again, so it’s hard to even think of someone to add… I cannot think of anyone on offense to add.”
The exercise ultimately reveals as much about Ohio State’s current roster strength as it does about the hosts’ wishlists. Even in a fantasy scenario with unlimited options, the consensus pointed to defensive tackle as the primary area of concern, with offensive additions largely seen as luxuries rather than necessities.
For the full breakdown and to hear all the fantasy draft selections, including which edge rushers and safeties received serious consideration, check out the complete Buckeye Talk episode.
Here’s the podcast for this week:
If the player above doesn’t work, you can listen to this week’s podcast here.
Note: Artificial intelligence was used to help generate this story from the Buckeye Talk Podcast by cleveland.com. Visitors to cleveland.com have asked for more text stories based on website podcast discussions.
This post was originally published on this site be sure to check out more of their content.
