Police reviews say pepper spray use justified amid Michigan-Ohio State postgame brawl

Reviews by two Ohio agencies concluded that law enforcement officials were justified in using pepper spray while breaking up the on-field brawl after the Michigan-Ohio State game in November.

The reviews, obtained through public-records requests, provide a fuller accounting of the postgame chaos — including the display of a Taser and a deputy striking a player — that marred the end of the Wolverines’ 13-10 win at Ohio State.

Advertisement

The scuffle began when Michigan players tried to plant a school flag at the center of Ohio Stadium. The situation devolved with one police officer suffering a head injury before the teams were finally separated. Videos and images of players and bystanders reeling from pepper spray went viral.

The review by the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office is unclear which agency first used the spray. One version of events said it was an officer from the University of Michigan Police Department based on “imminent/immediate officer safety” concerns, while another said a Franklin County deputy used it almost simultaneously.

A detective for The Ohio State University Police Division, Douglas Cunningham, said initial attempts to “suppress the aggressive, combative and growing crowd and to regain order” didn’t work.

“Several people were on the ground, police officers were being pushed and shoved by large, highly trained and skilled division one football athletes in full football game attire,” Cunningham wrote in his department’s report. “The players had the advantage in both size, strength, conditioning, protective gear and they outnumbered the police presence trying to suppress the growing threat.”

Cunningham wrote that he used a short burst of pepper spray because he thought it would “assist in gaining compliance from the aggression/resistance of the surging crowd.”

Three department officials, including the school’s chief of police, agreed it was reasonable.

Most of the actions by the sheriff’s office were also deemed appropriate, according to documents from its internal affairs bureau, including a threat to use a Taser

Lt. Shawn Pak wrote that a player — which body-cam footage shows as a 300-plus-pound lineman — tried to charge past him.

“Due to his size and protective gear, I placed my Taser into the unpadded section of his back, pushed him away from the crowd, and warned him I would use my Taser,” Pak wrote.

Advertisement

The Taser was never turned on, and the player walked away. The review determined the lieutenant’s action was justified.

The same was true of a strike and burst of pepper spray by Deputy Thomas Bellamy. He reported seeing a Michigan player standing over an Ohio State police officer.

“Due to the officer’s back and weapon being exposed and uncertain of the player’s intentions amidst the chaos … I used a single handstrike with a closed fist to the neck area (due to the player wearing a helmet and pads) in an effort to force him off the pile,” Bellamy wrote.

Bellamy later pulled out pepper spray and threatened to use it to cause the crowd to disperse. He wrote that another officer bumped his arm and triggered the spray, but he didn’t realize it “likely due to the difficulty of feeling the discharge while wearing winter gloves.”

A review agreed: “After many hours in the cold, his fingers were likely numb. However, intentional or not, the use of (pepper spray) effectively controlled this area of the growing hostile crowd.”

Though the review determined those actions were justified, he received a written reprimand for failing to disclose the use of force and not activating his body camera.

One fan was arrested in the incident: Abraham Clark, a 45-year-old Florida resident, who told Ohio State police that he ran onto the field “to prevent Michigan from planting their flag.” His criminal trespassing case remains pending with a court case set for March 11.

The Big Ten fined both teams $100,000 for violating the conference’s sportsmanship policy. No players were suspended, and the Buckeyes went on to win the national championship.

Required reading

(Photo: Joseph Maiorana / Imagn Images)