Major League Baseball’s century-old exemption from federal antitrust law is once again in the crosshairs on Capitol Hill. A bipartisan Senate bill would strip the league of the legal protection that has set it apart from every other major American sports league, according to PYMNTS.
Durbin and Lee team up
Sen. Dick Durbin, an Illinois Democrat, introduced the Competition in Professional Baseball Act, with Utah Republican Sen. Mike Lee signing on as a cosponsor. PYMNTS cited a Nov. 20 report by Traders Union that drew on information from the Senate Judiciary Committee.
The bill would repeal the exemption outright. Supporters argue that the protection gives MLB an unfair advantage by shielding parts of its business from federal competition law. Durbin has described the exemption as allowing baseball to operate as a legally protected monopoly and has questioned the reasoning behind the original Supreme Court decision that created baseball’s special treatment.
Lee’s involvement gives the measure bipartisan backing, though its chances of passing remain uncertain.
What would change
Unlike the NFL, NBA and NHL, MLB benefits from a judicially created exemption that limits how certain federal antitrust rules apply to its operations. Removing it could open more of the league’s business to legal challenges under competition law, potentially affecting how MLB structures commercial relationships and exercises control over professional baseball.
The bill would not, on its own, establish that MLB has broken any antitrust rules. Instead, it would remove the special shield that currently limits certain lawsuits against the league.
Years of scrutiny
The new push builds on years of congressional attention to baseball’s business practices, particularly its treatment of minor league players.
While chairing the Senate Judiciary Committee during the Biden administration, Durbin examined whether the exemption harmed competition in the labor market for minor leaguers. In June 2022 he contacted Advocates for Minor Leaguers about the issue, and the following month he sent an inquiry to MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred.
That scrutiny came before MLB recognized the unionization of minor league players under the Major League Baseball Players Association in September 2022, giving those players a formal collective bargaining framework for the first time.
Congressional interest did not end there. In November 2023, Durbin and other senators questioned Manfred about MLB’s efforts to secure broad exemptions from federal wage-and-hour rules while it was negotiating a labor deal covering minor leaguers. Durbin later introduced a separate measure, the Fair Ball Act, aimed at those labor concerns.
A bigger question
At its core, the bill asks whether baseball should keep legal protections unavailable to other professional sports businesses. Backers say the current framework limits accountability and leaves MLB in an unusually privileged position under federal law. The league’s critics now have a bipartisan vehicle to make that case, though the legislation still faces a long road through Congress.


