What we know about the Myles Garrett trade demand — and what’s next for the Browns

Super Bowl week started with a bang, and it had nothing to do with the game: On Monday, Cleveland Browns superstar edge rusher Myles Garrett publicly announced that he’s demanding a trade.

What’s next for the 29-year-old Garrett? And how do the Browns manage their unhappy star? We discussed on the latest episode of the “Scoop City” podcast.

The partial transcript below has been edited for clarity. You can listen to the full episode on Apple Podcasts and Spotify, or watch on YouTube above.

Dianna: For the last few weeks, the Cleveland Browns have known that Myles Garrett has wanted out. But on Monday, he publicly put out, “I want out.” It was a surprise for a lot of people. I think Browns fans are not as surprised. I think they’ve been reading the tea leaves and they’ve heard a lot of rumblings, but also the fact that Andrew Berry came out just a week ago at the Senior Bowl and he told us, “I’m not trading Myles Garrett.” Just a week later, this entire thing has shifted. The No. 1 pick in the 2017 draft now wants out of Cleveland. You heard the news. What was your reaction?

Advertisement

Chase: We had to talk about it on our Fox show, and the first thought was, “About time.” I would want out of Cleveland, too. You see the news and you hear about all the backstory. Then he actually writes a very nice letter, which you posted. You read it and you’re like, all right, the dude wants to win. Like you say all those things and you have one playoff win in eight seasons in Cleveland. You’re 2023 Defensive Player of the Year. Stats can only accumulate so much until you just are so sick and tired of losing, and that’s what Cleveland’s been doing.

Dianna: Well, the statement said, “While I’ve loved calling this city my home, my desire to win and compete on the biggest stage won’t allow me to be complacent. The goal was never to go from Cleveland to Canton. It has always been to compete for and win a Super Bowl.” Of course, the “Cleveland to Canton” line draws attention because Andrew Berry said that about Garrett twice in January when discussing the team’s plans to keep him. All of this is very much orchestrated. OK. This obviously drops the week of the Super Bowl, where we’re all going to be talking.

Chase: Yeah, Monday the week of the Super Bowl. Like come on.

Dianna: Chase, when I tell you there is nothing going on outside of the coaching cycle, there is zero going on. So this was a bombshell. The Browns, as I mentioned, knew this was coming. They were informed this morning that Garrett was going to go public with it. I spoke to some people around the league about it and somebody, even in Cleveland, just in response to how they’re taking the seriousness of it. Their response was, essentially: If he’s going public like this, he is serious about this. This isn’t just a game to get another contract. This isn’t a wink, wink, little move (saying) I’m unhappy. We saw in San Francisco. We saw Deebo Samuel want out publicly. He came out and said he wanted a trade, but he stayed. Brandon Aiyuk came out and publicly said, “I want a trade.” They did some work — he stayed. Just because you go public doesn’t mean it’s definitely going to happen. At the same time, I think a player of this caliber being this disgruntled and this angry, I think the Cleveland Browns know that they’ve got a mess on their hands here.

Advertisement

Chase: It almost seems to me, when you go public and you’re this big of a star player — last year’s Defensive Player of the Year, one of the premier pass rushers at the premier position in all of the NFL besides quarterback — when you go public with this, you mean business. In my opinion, there’s no way that they’re going to end up back together, and quite honestly, he almost has all the power. Only a $19 million cap hit next year. He’s going to be in line for an extension. It’s almost like he could pick his own team. Look at those teams that need pass-rush help that can fit them under the cap. They can sign him to an extension that can finagle the cap space in certain teams.

Dianna: You have to consider a couple of things. One, you’re right — he’s going to want a new contract. Not only is it going to be a new contract, it’s going to be a contract that’s going to pay him the most at that position, the highest of a non-quarterback. This isn’t going to be some friendly little deal he’s going to do with a new team. He wants to be the highest paid at his position, and rightfully so. You have to consider that when we’re trying to piece together who are the teams (he could go to). Before we get into the teams, though, I want to let you know that the Cleveland Browns are standing by what they said last week, which is, “We are not trading Myles Garrett.” In fact, I reached out to them this morning, and it was the same thing: We are not moving on this. We’re not even going to entertain phone calls.

Chase: That’s ridiculous. Like, I get it, and I would have that stance too. But as soon as someone offers you two ones or a one and two twos, you’re going to move on from the player. In my opinion, this is a full-on rebuild in Cleveland. Deshaun Watson, probably not playing this year depending on how he recovers, that whole guaranteed money. I think this was sort of writing on the wall for Myles Garrett when they signed Deshaun Watson and he never panned out. I bet Myles Garrett — and I can’t take words out of his mouth — but I’m thinking from a star player standpoint, probably what he’s saying is like, “Man, we got Deshaun Watson from the Houston Texans in 2019, that was the only piece that was missing. We let go of Baker because he wasn’t the guy. We got some really good offensive pieces. We have a two-time Coach of the Year. We have a killer defense with (Jim) Schwartz. This is our year!” They made the playoffs with Joe Flacco. You know what I mean? He sees the writing on the wall.

Dianna: Well, let’s say that there is a world where the Browns think they could keep him. What could an organization do?

Chase: Nothing. As soon as you go public and you’re a star player, you were as good as out. I was talking to Shady McCoy, a superstar who’s been traded in his prime from the Philadelphia Eagles to the Buffalo Bills. And he said, “I didn’t want to be traded, but I didn’t have a choice.” It’s different, but it’s the same because they’re star players. Star players have so much more power over the locker room. He is the leader of that team. As soon as the leader, your stud player, your Hall of Fame player wants out, there’s no mending fences.

Advertisement

Dianna: So what would it look like if a team were able to get him? I reached out to a few GMs around the league who are all paying close attention to this, and I’m sure a lot of them are probably already reaching out to Andrew Berry to see how serious they are about not moving on. Just trying to get a feel for what he could go for. One GM said a one and a two, a one and two threes, maybe throw a player in there. And that was the most common answer I did get today in terms of what it would cost. I do think that they could maybe squeeze another team for slightly more, for a team that is close to winning. Because that’s another factor in this: Myles wants to play for a contender, or at least somebody that is close to contending. It kind of killed my Raiders idea. Actually, it was the GM who said the Raiders should consider trading for Myles Garrett to pair him up with Maxx Crosby. What better way to take down Patrick Mahomes than that? There’s your answer, but I doubt that’s going to happen.

Chase: So what you’re saying is a little less than Kahlil (Mack)? Because I was with Kahlil Mack when he got traded at 27 years old to the Chicago Bears. We gave up a ton. But what you’re saying — Myles at 29 is probably going to be a little bit less than what Khalil Mack garnered? I’m trying to draw comparisons to this situation because they’re both really freaking good pass rushers. That makes sense to me. A one and a two, maybe a late-round pick. I mean, that’s still really expensive for GMs.

Dianna: So there’s no permanent or definite timeline for stuff like this, but I can tell you that most teams want to get this type of trade done before the new league year. That’s about four weeks. I think we’re going to see some action here over that time.

Chase: Let me ask you a question: Do you think, to the best of your knowledge, that if we knew at the time of all the hiring cycles and firing cycles of head coaches this year, that Deshaun Watson was not going to be the quarterback for the Cleveland Browns moving forward because of his injury, and that Myles Garrett was not going to be the premier player still on that team, do Andrew Berry and Kevin Stefanski survive? Are they still the coach and GM to lead this rebuild if both of those guys were gone?

Dianna: Yeah, I think I think that’s what ownership decided. They were going to stick with Andrew Berry and Kevin Stefanski because he has that belief. I understand what you’re saying, that Myles Garrett is such a big piece of this and the idea of losing him, they really have to start this thing over. But I think they’re already there in their minds, of “How we can fix some of these issues?” It’s why I think they’re going to probably go quarterback in the draft to try to fix that.

Chase: Really?! Hold on, hold on. You just blew my socks off. Quarterback at two in the draft?

Dianna: I don’t know if it’s definite.

Advertisement

Chase: You just said it so nonchalantly.

Dianna: I just think it makes sense. I think all the signs are pointing to that. Maybe not even one, maybe even two in this draft, knowing that that’s the position that they have to get right. The Deshaun Watson thing is not working out there. They’re sort of ripping the Band-Aid while also just letting Deshaun sit. I’m not really sure.

Chase: Give me two teams, where Garrett goes.

Dianna: Well, I think the things that you have to consider, as I mentioned before, is going to be a team that has the money to give him a contract like that, a team that can be contending. And I do think a 4-3 (defense) would probably have to be something that they can consider. The scheme in front is going to be part of this. Why not the Chargers? Why not the Commanders? What about the Eagles? Just keep loading up.

Chase: Oh, Howie. Trade everyone on that D-line except Jalen Carter, and put Jalen Carter and Myles Garrett together.

Dianna: I still like the Commanders idea. We know they traded away Chase Young and Montez Sweat. Just adding Garrett would just accelerate that rebuild that they’re doing. We saw what their biggest problem was: defense. This is where they need to get better.

Chase: Good one. I like that one a lot.

(Photo: Gregory Shamus / Getty Images)