Where LSU’s Garrett Nussmeier ranks in 2025 QB power rankings

LSU made improvements throughout its roster during the early months of the offseason. 

All of the players brought in were done so with the intent of reaching the college football playoff and making a run deep into the postseason. But at the end of the day, the play of Garrett Nussmeier at quarterback will be the most important piece to making a legitimate championship push.

This week, CBS Sports writer Tom Fernelli released a QB power rankings piece heading into spring ball and Nussmeier ranked No. 6 in the country. Nussmeier was ranked behind the likes of Arch Manning, Cade Klubnik, Carson Beck, Drew Allar and Sam Leavitt as programs around the country start spring practices. 

Here’s what was written about Nussmeier:

“Oh, Garrett, I’ll never stop being enamored with that cannon attached to your torso, nor should you. Of course, considering the throws I see you unleash at times, I don’t think I need to worry about it on your end. It’s clear you love that thing, and you love to show it off, which is what I love about you. However, it may be better for your draft stock and LSU’s ability to compete in the SEC if you harness it a little. Or don’t. It’s cool. You’re still here, right?”

It does appear the gunslinger stigma won’t be leaving Nussmeier anytime soon from a national perspective but there’s a legitimate argument to be made that the LSU quarterback will be much higher on this list at the conclusion of the 2025 season. 

Does Nussmeier need to cut back on the turnovers? Yes. Will he need to be more willing to escape the pocket and turn upfield when those opportunities are presented? Absolutely. 

While this is just one writer’s opinion, for Nussmeier to enter the spring this far down the list is questionable to say the least. Manning has great potential but hasn’t played enough to deserve the No. 1 spot. Beck had the same kind of turnover issues at Georgia a year ago and didn’t flash the same arm talent that Nussmeier did. 

Allar and Leavitt are solid college quarterbacks with college football playoff experience under their belts but also haven’t reached the ceiling from a passing perspective that Nussmeier has in 2024. A case can be made for Klubnik as that battle week one at Clemson will be very interesting as an early potential Heisman kind of statement game for both quarterbacks. 

Nussmeier is coming off a strong first year as a starter where he threw for over 4,000 yards and 29 touchdowns but the 12 interceptions and three fumbles lost looms large as a major point of development for him going into this offseason. We’ll get a chance to see just how much improvement there’s been in his game starting with spring ball but a lot of what will need to be shown won’t happen until he takes the field this fall. 

Part of what we can learn is how much the game has slowed down for him. There was a five game stretch last year during the middle of SEC play where Nussmeier threw nine interceptions and there were times the game looked a little bit sped up for him. He’s spoken about the growing pains in year one and how much he can take that experience into the coming months. 

“This first year was a huge growth year for me, learning who I am as a player. I hadn’t played football for three years so the feeling of getting hit again, shaking the cobwebs off, playing really good SEC defense and learning different things I need to improve. Learning when I need to take off, using my feet more,” Nussmeier said. 

Nussmeier has all the arm talent in the world to be one of the best quarterbacks in all of college football in 2025. Consistency will be a key part in his game taking that next step along with being more decisive in the pocket and keeping the ball out of harm’s way. 

All of that should come with a greater understanding of what to expect when those tough games against quality opponents get started from the very first week of the season. 

“I felt like the product I put out there for my teammates and these coaches who have put so much time in me, I feel like wasn’t as consistent as I wanted it to be. There’s a whole level that I can tap into and I felt like I owed my coaches, my teammates that opportunity for us to be playing at such a high level, where I’m playing at such a high level where we can go where we want it to go,” Nussmeier said.