UNC Basketball: Grading Hubert Davis’ coaching job for the 2024-25 season

Following the conclusion of the 2024-25 season, we graded every player on the roster this year to finish putting a bow on what was a roller coaster year. While there was a lot said about various players on the team, the one guy that was the biggest topic of conversation this season was the man in charge, Hubert Davis. Some people like him, some people hate him, some people want him fired, and some people want him to have another year or two to see what he can do with the new GM. There’s a lot of takes floating around out there, and truly however you feel isn’t wrong or right, it is just how you feel. Being a college basketball head coach in the year of our Lord 2025 is interesting to say the least. I think we all can agree that it is significantly harder than it was 10 years ago if you don’t know what you’re doing. Yes, I am talking specifically about the transfer portal and NIL aspect of things.

When it comes to Hubert Davis, it’s pretty clear that while he has been more capable of navigating the portal and NIL than maybe Roy Williams would’ve been, he is not even close to being the best at it. Duke, UConn, most of the SEC, and for some reason BYU(???) have all had a much better time doing this dance than UNC has, which was at least one part of why the 2024-25 season was an uphill battle. It really felt like all Hubert Davis needed was an experienced senior that could do some of the dirty work that Armando Bacot did, and he wasn’t able to get them in the offseason. It wasn’t for lack of trying, which honestly raises more questions than it answers. Was the budget that tight for Carolina? Did Davis just not make good enough pitches? We may never know, but all I know is it made things pretty difficult when it came to this team’s size considering the fact that everyone else was already relatively undersized compared to other teams.

When it came to what happened on the court, things weren’t much clearer. I’ve lost several nights of sleep trying to figure out why the Heels showed up to Quad 1 games playing poor first halves, only to come out in the final 20 minutes looking like one of the best teams in the country…for about 15 minutes. In the final five minutes it felt like the team went back into their shell, and we all know what happened from there. Here’s the thing: I don’t know how the heck this happens in basketball, whether it’s college basketball or the NBA. I’m a Chicago Bulls fan, and ever since Zach Lavine was traded, the Bulls have done somewhat similar things in their games, but they have managed to win them. Does it mean Billy Donovan is a bad coach? Not necessarily. Does what happened with UNC mean Hubert Davis is a bad coach? I also am inclined to say no, but I do think he takes ownership for why that happened so often early in the season.

To elaborate, I think this team suffered from two pretty big problems aside from the center situation. I think this team took a really long time to figure out how to function with RJ Davis being “the guy” on this team. I think the players took a while to figure it out, I think RJ took a while to figure it out, and most importantly, I think it took Hubert Davis a while to figure it out. This led to a lot of different rotations, especially with the starting lineup. I don’t remember a season where I saw so many different starting lineups. Hubert gets credit for doing everything he could to find the sweet spot, and eventually he kind of did. However, a pessimist would ask why it took so long, and to that I say: I have no idea.

When it came to the defensive side of the ball, that was another head-scratcher when it came to Davis. For a lot of the season it felt like he was having the Heels play a pretty one-dimensional style of defense, and it wasn’t until deeper into the season where we started seeing more traps, some zone, different methods of dealing with ball screens, etc. Teams started having a harder time when they didn’t know what was coming, and ultimately it led to forcing more turnovers, which meant they had a lot more fast break / secondary break opportunities instead of being relegated to running half court offense. To really sum things up: it felt like Hubert Davis a number of the right things eventually, but it took him a while to get there this season.

To me, I think Hubert Davis could’ve done a much better coaching job this season, but at the same time I don’t feel like he should be on the hot seat just yet either. I think there were a number of things that he experienced that served as learning experiences for him. He learned that his system doesn’t work if he can’t get the correct pieces in the portal, he needs more vocal leaders on his roster, and most importantly, he needed someone to handle the NIL mess that comes with modern day college basketball. If he solves all of these problems in the offseason and the Heels are still struggling to get into the NCAA Tournament field? Yes, his seat should be scorching hot.

But I think we need to ask ourselves: what do we think would be acceptable improvement? Everyone will have a different answer to the question, so I guess in a way, he’s damned if he does and damned if he doesn’t. With no more Hall of Fame coaches with Carolina ties waiting to take over, I personally think a fair expectation is that 1.) you are a top 2 or 3 ACC team, 2.) you comfortably make the NCAA Tournament, and 3.) you make it to the second weekend. The ACC is bad now, so I don’t think I’m asking a lot.

We’ll see how things turn out in November, but for now, I’m giving Hubert Davis a 70% for the season, which is good enough for a C-. He deserves credit for eventually figuring out a number of things in February and March, but the sub-optimal roster construction and frustrating Quad 1 losses almost made me lower his grade to a solid D. What do you think of Hubert Davis’ coaching job during the 2024-25 season? Let us know in the comments below.